Right to remain silent
Technical assessment of whether to answer questions or exercise the right to remain silent.
Assistance during the investigative phase: notices, summonses to appear, questioning of the suspect, searches, seizures, defence submissions and assessment of how best to act in the proceedings.
Before going to the police or the prosecutor, the document received must be reviewed: who is summoning, in which proceeding, in what procedural capacity, with which warnings and for what activity.
A summons to appear is not automatically the same as questioning. It may concern different activities and must be read in its actual wording. The technical qualification of the document affects preparation, available rights and the precautions to be taken.
The defence also reviews deadlines, service of documents, description of the alleged facts, suspected offences, previous investigative acts and possible room for defence investigations or communication with the public prosecutor.
The decision on procedural conduct must derive from the documents available and from the assessment of evidential and precautionary risk.
Technical assessment of whether to answer questions or exercise the right to remain silent.
Preparation of statements only when they are useful, consistent with the documents and sustainable in light of the material already collected.
Assessment of written submissions, documents, defence investigations or evidentiary requests at the stage in which they may actually matter.
Searches, seizures and the acquisition of phones, computers, documents or digital data can have a major impact on the defence. Grounds, execution, reports, the object of the measure and available remedies must be checked.
The review concerns not only formal legality, but also the effect of the measure on the reconstruction of the facts and on the suspect’s personal, work or professional position.
Where appropriate, the defence assesses requests for return, review of the seizure, objections, written submissions or access to the documents allowed by law.
It depends on the capacity in which you are summoned. A suspect is entitled to a defence lawyer and may remain silent; a person summoned as a witness must tell the truth. Before attending, have the document reviewed by a defence lawyer.
No. Making statements may be useful, but it may also create difficulties. The decision depends on the documents available, the allegation, the material collected and the defence strategy.
The report, the object of the seizure, the authority involved, the grounds of the measure and any remedies must be examined immediately, including return requests or review where available.

Avv. Gerardo Di Maria
Criminal lawyer, member of the Salerno Bar; he has worked in criminal law since 2014. Office in Piazza Umberto I, n. 1, Salerno, Italy. Works in English and Italian.
For an assessment, please send the document received: summons to appear, notice, search order, seizure report, appointment notice or authority communication.
Office in Piazza Umberto I, n. 1, 84121 Salerno, Italy. Criminal defence assistance during preliminary investigations, including summonses to appear, questioning, searches and seizures.